logo CityLand
      • Home
      • About CityLand
      • CityLand Sponsors
      • Filings & Decisions
      • Commentary
      • Archive
      • Resources
      • CityLaw
      • Current Issue

    Court compels DEC to accept brownfield application


    Court Decisions  •  NYSDEC  •  Chelsea, Manhattan
    10/15/2008   •    Leave a Comment

    DEC overstepped its authority by judging application against eligibility regulations not found in Brownfield statute. HLP Properties LLC owned a 1.75 acre surface parking lot bounded by West 17th and 18th Streets between 10th and 11th Avenues in Manhattan. The lot was part of the former West 18th Street manufactured gas plant, a 19th century facility that converted coal to combustible gas for all of Manhattan north of Canal Street. The plant operated for more than sixty years, depositing substantial amounts of hazardous contaminants into the surrounding property.

    As part of HLP’s plan to develop the parking lot into two mixed-use high-rise towers, HLP submitted an application to the NYS Department of Environmental Conservation for entry into the Brownfield Cleanup Program. The Brownfield Cleanup Program Act of 2003 was enacted to encourage voluntary cleanup of hazardous waste sites and return them to constructive use. If accepted, HLP would be eligible for tax credits and liability limitations upon completing the required remediation.

    DEC denied HLP’s brownfield application partly because it did not believe the property could be considered economically unattractive for development, given its close proximity to the High Line and its inclusion in a recent rezoning. 2 CityLand 83 (July 15, 2005). DEC also denied the application because it found that development of the site would not be complicated by the contamination since Con Edison, a former owner of the site, agreed to perform the necessary remediation.

    Judge Walter B. Tolub reversed DEC’s denial of HLP’s brownfield application and required DEC to accept HLP’s property into the Brownfield Cleanup Program. Tolub ruled that DEC’s self-created economic eligibility criteria was not supported by the clear language of the statute, was contrary to the legislature’s intent to promote remediation and redevelopment, and amounted to an unacceptable exercise in lawmaking. The court found that the plain meaning of brownfield, as contained in the statute, included any piece of real estate, the redevelopment of which may be complicated by contamination. Since the court found that HLP’s property satisfied the statutory definition, it compelled DEC to accept HLP’s application.

    HLP Properties LLC v. New York State Dept. of Environmental Conservation, 2008 NY Slip Op. 28337, (Sept. 12, 2008) (Tolub, J.) (Attorneys: Gibson Dunn & Crutcher LLP, Sive Paget & Riesel PC, for HLP; Normal Spiegel, for NYSDEC).

    Share this:

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Email
    Tags : Brownfield Cleanup Program, HLP Properties LLC, Judge Walter B. Tolub
    Category : Court Decisions

    Comment on this article

    Click here to cancel reply.

    Subscribe To Free Alerts


    Follow Us on Social Media

    twitterfacebook

    Search

    Search by Category

      City Council
      CityLaw
      City Planning Commission
      Board of Standards & Appeals
      Landmarks Preservation Commission
      Economic Development Corporation
      Housing Preservation & Development
      Administrative Decisions
      Court Decisions
      Filings and Decisions
      CityLand Profiles

    Search by Date

    © 1997-2010 New York Law School | 185 West Broadway, New York, NY 10013 | 212.431.2100 | Privacy | Terms | Code of Conduct | DMCA | Policies