logo CityLand
      • Home
      • About CityLand
      • CityLand Sponsors
      • Filings & Decisions
      • Commentary
      • Archive
      • Resources
      • CityLaw
      • Current Issue

    Discriminatory Property Tax Case Dismissed


    Court Decisions  •  Property Tax  •  Citywide
    12/28/2016   •    Leave a Comment
    Image Credit: nyc.gov

    Image Credit: nyc.gov

    Tenant alleged that the City’s allocation of the property tax burden violated due process and equal protection. Ernest Robinson sought declaratory and injunctive relief alleging that the City’s property tax classification system created a disparate and adverse impact on African-American and Hispanic residents, deprived them of due process and equal protection of the laws, and violated the Fair Housing Act. Robinson alleged that the Class Two tax burden, heavily made up of rental multiple dwellings, was borne primarily by minority tenants, and that approximately 30 percent of a tenant’s rental payment was attributable to the landlord’s property tax.

    The Supreme Court of New York County dismissed the case, ruling that Robinson lacked standing to sue. Justice Frank Nervo found that Robinson failed to show he suffered an actual harm. Robinson did not show that the tax plan had a disparate impact based on race or ethnicity, nor did he show that white tenants were subject to a different tax treatment. The allegation that 30 percent of a tenant’s rent went to property tax was speculative and not established by any evidence.

    The First Department affirmed the decision, dismissing the complaint. The Court ruled that a statistical imbalance without a showing of similarly situated tenants receiving different treatment or forced segregation was not enough to establish a violation of the Fair Housing Act.

    Robinson v. City of New York, 2016 NY Slip Op 07083 (1st Dep’t Oct. 27, 2016) (Attorneys: Peter Safirstein, for Robinson; Zachary W. Carter, Jeremy W. Shweder, for the City; Eric T. Schneiderman, Seth Rokosky, for the State).

    By: Jonathon Sizemore (Jonathon is the CityLaw Fellow and a New York Law School Graduate, Class of 2016).

    Share this:

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Email
    Tags : Due Process, Equal Protection, Fair Housing Act, New York City Property Tax
    Category : Court Decisions

    Comment on this article

    Click here to cancel reply.

    Subscribe To Free Alerts

    In a Reader

    Desktop Reader Bloglines Google Live Netvibes Newsgator Yahoo! What's This?

    Follow Us on Social Media

    twitterfacebook

    Search

    Search by Category

      City Council
      CityLaw
      City Planning Commission
      Board of Standards & Appeals
      Landmarks Preservation Commission
      Economic Development Corporation
      Housing Preservation & Development
      Administrative Decisions
      Court Decisions
      Filings and Decisions
      CityLand Profiles

    Search by Date

    © 1997-2010 New York Law School | 185 West Broadway, New York, NY 10013 | 212.431.2100 | Privacy | Terms | Code of Conduct | DMCA | Policies
    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.