logo CityLand
      • Home
      • About CityLand
      • CityLand Sponsors
      • Filings & Decisions
      • Commentary
      • Archive
      • Resources
      • CityLaw
      • Current Issue

    Court Upholds Zoning Restriction On Peace Sign


    Court Decisions  •  Free Speech  •  Upper West Side, Manhattan
    01/05/2016   •    (2) Comments

    Zoning resolution prohibited apartment dweller from placing illuminated “Peace” sign in 17th floor window. In 2010 Brigitte Vosse placed an illuminated “Peace” sign in the window of her seventeenth-floor condo in The Ansonia at 2109 Broadway in the Upper West Side of Manhattan.  The Department of Buildings fined her $800 for violating a zoning ordinance restricting illuminated signs in her neighborhood at heights above forty feet.  Vosse argued that the City placed a content-based restriction on her speech, citing an exemption in the Zoning Resolution for flags, banners, or pennants of a civic, philanthropic, educational, or religious nature.  Vosse also argued even if content-neutral, the regulation was an unreasonable “time, place, and manner” restriction on her speech.

    On August 1, 2013 U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff denied Vosse’s motion for summary judgment for lack of standing for a content-based discrimination challenge and granted the City’s motion to dismiss.  On January 12, 2015 the Second Circuit Court of Appeals granted Vosse’s petition for rehearing on her time, place, and manner argument and remanded the case back to the Southern District.  Vosse argued that the City failed to show that the restriction served a sufficiently real and significant governmental interest.  The City argued the prohibition on illuminated signs forty feet or more above curb level furthered the government’s interest in preserving neighborhood character and aesthetics.

    On November 18, 2015 District Judge Jed Rakoff of the Southern District of New York ruled for the City and dismissed the complaint with prejudice.  The judge ruled that the Zoning Resolution did not prohibit all signs forty feet or more above curb level, but allowed non-illuminated signs twelve square feet in size or less, resulting in a restriction narrowly tailored to achieve the City’s interest and allowing for adequate alternatives to communicate the same message.  Had Vosse’s sign been non-illuminated, the judge held, she could have displayed it in the same manner and not been in violation of the Resolution.

    Vosse v. NYC, 12 Civ. 8004, NYLJ 1202743491138, at *1 (SDNY, Decided Nov. 18, 2015)

    Share this:

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Email
    Tags : First Amendment, Southern District of New York, The Ansonia, zoning resolution
    Category : Court Decisions

    Responses to “Court Upholds Zoning Restriction On Peace Sign”

    1. Terry Grace says:
      January 5, 2016 at 12:41 pm

      So what about lit Christmas trees and decorations on balconies and in windows?

      Reply
    2. Leo says:
      January 5, 2016 at 3:45 pm

      Funny, I was just thinking today about how the City allowed the two enormous (30’w x 80’h?) digital screens on 6th avenue at 33rd Street? I’m pretty sure the Times Square special zoning for signs was restricted to Times Square. So how did Mr. Dolan transport those rules to his far- away property? Or did he just do it without DCP or DOB weighing in?

      Reply

    Comment on this article

    Click here to cancel reply.

    Subscribe To Free Alerts

    In a Reader

    Desktop Reader Bloglines Google Live Netvibes Newsgator Yahoo! What's This?

    Follow Us on Social Media

    twitterfacebook

    Search

    Search by Category

      City Council
      CityLaw
      City Planning Commission
      Board of Standards & Appeals
      Landmarks Preservation Commission
      Economic Development Corporation
      Housing Preservation & Development
      Administrative Decisions
      Court Decisions
      Filings and Decisions
      CityLand Profiles

    Search by Date

    © 1997-2010 New York Law School | 185 West Broadway, New York, NY 10013 | 212.431.2100 | Privacy | Terms | Code of Conduct | DMCA | Policies
    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.