logo CityLand
      • Home
      • About CityLand
      • CityLand Sponsors
      • Filings & Decisions
      • Commentary
      • Archive
      • Resources
      • CityLaw
      • Current Issue

    Brooklyn owner wins right to complete construction


    Board of Standards & Appeals  •  Vested Right  •  Homecrest, Brooklyn
    02/15/2009   •    Leave a Comment

     

    1610 Avenue S. Photo: CityLand.

    Board rules that excavation and foundation work completed prior to permit revocation is still considered in vested rights analysis if revocation is later rescinded. On January 11, 2006, the Department of Buildings issued a permit to the owner of 1610 Avenue S to construct a six-story 25-unit residential building with community facility use on the first floor. After a special audit review, Buildings notified the owner of its intent to revoke the permit unless certain zoning and Building Code objections were resolved. Though the owner completed excavation and began work on the foundation, it failed to resolve the objections, and Buildings revoked the permit on February 14, 2006. The next day, the City Council approved a rezoning in Homecrest which changed the zoning on the owner’s lot from R6 to R4-1. The owner eventually resolved all the objections, and Buildings rescinded all outstanding letters of intent to revoke; however, the zoning change caused the proposed development to be out-of-compliance, and the owner filed an appeal with BSA to complete construction.

    Elected officials, Brooklyn Community Board 15, and the Madison-Marine-Homecrest Civic Association all opposed the application. They claimed that the owner had not obtained a vested right to complete construction since the excavation and foundation work completed through February 14, 2006 was performed pursuant to an invalid permit. They also argued that substantial construction had not been performed because the east and south walls could not be considered permitted foundation walls since they were shoring walls that would need to be replaced. The opposition also believed that the presence of “shoddy” work allowed BSA to deny the permit, and that the owner’s allegedly false statements about the work performed required BSA to deny the application.

    BSA disagreed with the opposition, and ruled that the applicant had obtained a vested right to complete construction. Although Buildings had revoked the owner’s permit, BSA found that Buildings’ rescission of the revocation restored the owner’s rights as if they were never taken away, and thus, excavation and foundation work performed prior to the revocation could be counted towards a vested rights analysis. BSA also determined that the amount of work completed at the site amounted to substantial construction even if the east and south walls did not factor into the analysis. Turning to the issue of “shoddy” work, BSA explained that it could not make a decision regarding the adequacy of work performed because such work was within Buildings’ purview. Lastly, BSA declined to consider any argument regarding the owner’s alleged false statements, and reminded the opposition that since BSA was an administrative body, it could not base its decision on principles of equity or fairness.

    BSA: 1610 Ave. S, Brooklyn (266-07-A, 191-08-BZY) (Dec. 9, 2008) (Stuart A. Klein, for owner). CITYADMIN

    Share this:

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Google
    • Email
    Tags : 1610 Avenue S, Brooklyn Community Board 15, Madison-Marine-Homecrest Civic Association
    Category : Board of Standards & Appeals

    Comment on this article

    Click here to cancel reply.

    Subscribe To Free Alerts

    In a Reader

    Desktop Reader Bloglines Google Live Netvibes Newsgator Yahoo! What's This?

    Follow Us on Social Media

    twitterfacebook

    Search

    Search by Category

      City Council
      CityLaw
      City Planning Commission
      Board of Standards & Appeals
      Landmarks Preservation Commission
      Economic Development Corporation
      Housing Preservation & Development
      Administrative Decisions
      Court Decisions
      Filings and Decisions
      CityLand Profiles

    Search by Date

    © 1997-2010 New York Law School | 185 West Broadway, New York, NY 10013 | 212.431.2100 | Privacy | Terms | Code of Conduct | DMCA | Policies
    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.